Our Story

Our Story

Meat is meat.
It's the seasoning.

A market table, a little red trailer, two burger joints and a food truck. Seven awards. The same blends the whole way.

Shop the SeasoningsFind the Truck

How we got here

From a tailgate to your kitchen

Big Dad's Grilling Dust n More market table in 2010 with BBQ sauces, rubs and a Free BBQ Samples sign
Free samples. Still our best salesman.
2010

Big Dad's Grilling Dust n More

It started with the seasoning. A pop-up tent, the back of an SUV, a chalkboard that said "Free BBQ Samples!" and a banner with a slogan we still use today: Flavor Your Meat. People tried it, bought a bottle, and came back the next weekend for three.

Customers lined up at the red Big Dad's Nappy-Q food trailer in 2011
The little red trailer
2011

Big Dad's Nappy-Q

We opened a food trailer to sell BBQ with our own rubs and sauces. Mild Seas-n-All was born right here as that BBQ rub. Turns out smoking meat for 14 hours on a trailer is a great way to never sleep. Burgers, though? We were good at burgers. The line said so.

Between the Bun's first building in Indianapolis with classic cars parked out front
Car-show nights at the little white house
2012

Between the Bun opens

A little white house turned thick-burger joint, grilled backyard style. 100+ burger combinations, a lot of classic cars in the parking lot, and the start of a trophy run.

Between the Bun's final restaurant location, opened in 2018
Bigger kitchen. Same burgers.
2018

Bigger kitchen, same seasoning

Between the Bun moved into its final home. More seats, more grill space, and not one change to the blends. Eleven years in a building was a good run, and in fall 2023 we closed the doors.

The Smash Daddy's food truck serving smash burgers and selling handmade sauces and seasonings
Big Dad got his name back on the truck
2024

Smash Daddy's hits the road

We traded the building for wheels. Thick burgers became smash burgers. The blends didn't change one grain. Today the same bottles we cook with on the truck are made to order and shipped straight to your kitchen.

Scott Sims accepting the 2015 Indy Burger Battle award for Between the Bun
Indy Burger Battle, 2015

The trophy shelf

Don't take our word for it.

Indianapolis already voted.

  • WinnerIndy A-List Best Burger in Indy, 2017
  • ChampionIndy Burger Battle, 2015
  • WinnerIndy A-List Best Hot Dog in Indy, 2014
  • Runner-UpIndy A-List Best Burger in Indy, 2014 & 2015
  • Runner-UpIndy Burger Battle, 2014
  • Runner-UpBull Burger Battle, 2016

Every one of those burgers was seasoned with what's in our bottles.

Mild Seas-n-All

"Fry crack."

Our customers named it. We didn't argue.

It started as a BBQ rub on the Nappy-Q trailer. Then people put it on their fries. Then their eggs, their popcorn, their chicken and everything else. It's been on every burger we've served for 15 years, and it's made with turbinado sugar instead of plain white sugar for a deeper, caramelized flavor.

Get the Fry Crack

Why it tastes different

Us vs. the grocery aisle

Smash Daddy's The grocery aisle
Made To order, in small batches Months before it hits the shelf
Sweetened with Turbinado sugar Plain white sugar or corn syrup
Preservatives None. Ever. Usually
Tested on 15 years of real customers at a restaurant and a food truck A focus group
Scott Sims, founder of Smash Daddy's, carrying a tray of sliders at a Between the Bun burger competition
The guy behind the grill

From the founder

"I've been mixing these blends since 2010. They've been on every burger I've ever sold, from a market table to a restaurant to a food truck. When you buy a bottle, you're getting exactly what goes on our food. Nothing watered down for retail. Now go make something worth talking about."
Scott Sims

Founder, Smash Daddy's

2010
Blending since
7
Local awards
100+
Burger combos
0
Preservatives

Welcome to the family.

Now go fire up the grill.

Shop Sauces & SeasoningsBook the Truck